Categories: ARCSt. Martin's Press

Private School Secrets in “Madam”

You guys, this book.

I was interested in Madam, by Phoebe Wynne, as soon as the publicist mentioned The Secret History and Rebecca, but I couldn’t start it immediately because I just started a new teaching post. More on that in a moment.

In Madam, Rose Christie is a mid-twenties classics teacher, who’s offered a dream job at an upscale girls’ school in Scotland. I love stories set in girls’ schools, and the isolated campus was perfect. This is a creeping gothic novel where everything is just a little off,  but the protag has the practicality that comes from classroom teaching and the example of her historical women, from Dido to Medea.

I wasn’t able to start reading this one immediately because I’ve just changed jobs. I accepted a higher-paid, more prestigious teaching job at a new university, a great career opp, especially in covid times. In this dystopian hellscape of online teaching, my first weeks have been full of new colleagues promising to give me essential information and then disappearing, or promised orientation meetings being postponed until long after classes have started. It’s not ideal.

At first, Rose has the same situation in her new job. Other teachers make vague references to the important things their girls are doing, and the unexplained extra lessons they’re taking, and promise that everything will be explained soon. Really soon. Not right now, of course, just keep teaching lessons.  There are these constant gothic hints that something is very wrong at this posh boarding school and something very dark is happening just off-screen, blended with some realistically snotty teenage students rolling their eyes and telling Rose that she really doesn’t know anything yet.

As Rose discovers what’s actually happening at her new job, there’s an even creepier investigation about who is complicit and connected, and what everyone around her is getting out of working or studying at Caldonbrae Hall. A lot of the students are legacies, and all are from upper-class, well-connected families. Some of graduates stay on in cushy teaching or “pastoral” roles. Seems like (almost) everyone around Rose just loves the school community and the opportunities it provides.

This novel is an absolute page-turner, because I was so desperate to figure out just what Rose had gotten herself into and especially what had happened to the previous classics teacher.

Madam will be out from St. Martin’s Press on May 18, 2021. Thanks to the publisher for the advance copy. Opinions are my own, obvs.

View Comments

  • First, congrats on the new job! I love that you could relate a tiny bit to the MC because of that. This one sounds very good!

    -Lauren

    • Thanks! Waiting to hear school info while the protag was waiting to hear school info BUT IN AN OMINOUS WAY made it extra intense.

Recent Posts

Sandwich

I wanted to read Catherine Newman's new novel Sandwich as soon as I heard about…

The Midnight Feast, by Lucy Foley

The Midnight Feast, the newest thriller from Lucy Foley, takes place at the opening weekend…

Retro Book Review: Passenger to Frankfurt

Passenger to Frankfurt is not my favorite Christie mystery, at all. The spy ones and…

Imperfect by Katy Motiey

Imperfect, by Katy Motiey, tells the story of Vida, a young Iranian mother, and how the…

Lost on a Mountain in Maine

12-year-old Donn Fendler is on a family hike up a beautiful but challenging mountain, when…

The Pursuit of Mary Bennet

I picked up Pamela Mingle's The Pursuit of Mary Bennet after reading The Bennet Sisters'…